khar: well, from what i can gather, you pretty much banned jawbreaker from punx, which was a move based solely on your opinion on jawbreakers sound, and the sound that a punk band
should have, and judging from your punk recommendations, which consist mostly (seven out of eight) of punk bands from the 1970's uk, a punk band
should sound like one of those from the 1970's uk. it's a bit of a stretch, i'll admit, but it's a point that i wanted to make. as well, the illegitimacy of the sex pistols' message and all, though somewhat irrelevant and extraneous, was another. And i realize that most bands do not have legitimate politics, but some do. those are the ones i listen to. also, most bands do not gain a fanbase by preaching about the counter culture and anarchy, only to sell it out. this brings us to against me, supersheep.
And look at the bands that are 'anarchist' punk - Against Me! anyone?
they are not an anarcho punk band. sure, they garnered shitloads of support from the d.i.y. punk scene and got to where they are now by writing songs about anarchy and all things associated, but they quickly killed that good thing and signed to one of the major labels they once fought against. thus, and for the same reason why i don't listen to the sex pistols, i don't listen to against me. and yeah, you're right in thinking that music does not have to be political to be good. half the bands i listed in this thread alone don't say shit about it. but, if a band decides to have their politics define their music, then i would prefer them to actually believe in those politics.
If you want to listen to new punk listen to Leftover Crack or something.
i do listen to leftover crack. besides, jawbreaker isn't even new, they broke up ten years ago.
seriously, what the fuck is an anarcho punk?
when i say anarcho punk, i mean people who don't believe in the system and therefore do not allow their lives to be used to further it. drifters, squatters, people who don't eat processed and artificial foods and don't buy from harmful corporations, don't watch t.v., who eat from dumpsters and hitch rides. people who believe in and practice the politics they preach. the band crass as opposed to the sex pistols.
Man, you went to The Fest V. I am envying you so hard right now.
yeah, it was fucking nuts. its the one time of the year when it pays to live in florida. you should go to the next one, dude, totally fucking worth it. i had a friend fly in from arizona, and i met kids from north carolina, indiana, new york . . . . myself and a few friends drove 5 hours for the thing.
i think we've just shown why no one should ever try to discuss punk music. it always dissolves into senseless arguing.